Story #26: The Cat Who Chose Us
As told by Jackie Davis, Adopter & Donor
A Home Missing a Friend
We had just said goodbye to our big orange boy, and the silence in our home was overwhelming. He had been such a presence, and without him, everything felt off. After some time, we decided to stop by Anderson Humane just to look. We told ourselves we were only curious, only checking to see if any orange cats might remind us of the one we had lost.
There were no orange cats that day. Instead, a staff member gently suggested we meet a long-haired black and white adult boy named Sir Frosty. She explained that he had recently been adopted and returned within just three days because he was described as too affectionate, too friendly, and too vocal.
To us, that sounded like a cat who simply had too much love to give.
The Moment He Chose Us
Sir Frosty was resting in a floor crate. When we opened the door, my husband sat down on the floor. Without hesitation, Sir Frosty stepped out, walked straight over, and climbed into his lap. It was one of those moments where nothing else needed to be said. We looked at each other and knew he was coming home with us.
Grief has a way of opening your heart in unexpected moments, and that was one of them.
Bringing him home was effortless.
Once home, Sir Frosty became Dusty. The name fit him perfectly. From the very beginning, he settled in as if he had always belonged. There was no need to separate him from our other two cats. He moved through the house with confidence and ease, playing with our younger cat and coexisting peacefully with our older girl, who preferred to keep her distance.
Dusty brought a presence that was entirely his own. I have had cats my entire adult life, but this boy is something special. His affection is constant, his personality larger than life, and his ability to connect feels rare.
We still find ourselves wondering how anyone could return a cat like him, but we are endlessly grateful they did. Dusty has made our lives happier in ways we did not realize we were missing. He brought joy back into our home and gave our younger cat a companion who truly understands him.
I have supported Anderson Humane for years, but this experience reminded me just how deeply their work matters. Sometimes you go looking for one thing and find something completely different.
And sometimes, that unexpected love is exactly what your heart is looking for.
Ready to start your own rescue story?
Meet adoptable animals at Anderson Humane by visiting ahconnects.org/adopt, or help make the next 60 stories possible by donating in honor of our 60th Anniversary.
Interested in becoming a Volunteer?
Visit ahconnects.org/volunteer/ for more information on how you can get involved.
Interested in starting your own Foster Journey?
Visit us at ahconnects.org/foster-2/ for more information or email fosters@ahconnects.org
